“Swanee River”
Composed by Stephen Foster; arranged by Larry Clinton and Bunny Berigan.
Recorded by Bunny Berigan and His Orchestra for Victor on May 13, 1937 in New York.
Bunny Berigan, trumpet, directing: Steve Lipkins, first trumpet and Cliff (Natoli) Natalie, trumpet; Frankie D’Annolfo and Ford Leary, trombones; Sid Perlmutter, first alto saxophone; Hank Freeman, alto saxophone; Georgie Auld and Clyde Rounds, tenor saxophones; Joe Lippman, piano; Tom Morganelli, guitar; Arnold Fishkind, bass; George Wettling, drums.
The story – part one – Bunny Berigan getting started:
It is not ironic that many people remember Bunny Berigan because of the Vernon Duke/Ira Gershwin song “I Can’t Get Started with You,” which he made a great recording of and used as his theme song. In the many decades since that recoring was issued, his playing and singing on it have remained attractive to people who are interested in the music of the swing era. What is ironic however is that people who have commented on Berigan’s music and career since then have too often succumbed to the temptation to use that song title as a facile description of his life and career. If one examines the facts, it quickly becomes apparent that Berigan’s career for the most part followed an upward arc of success from its beginning in the mid 1920s until the end of the year 1938. Then, for several reasons, some of which were Bunny’s fault and some of which were not, his career began to ebb.

This post traces Berigan’s early days as a bandleader. That time can aptly be summarized as a succession of positive developments which mostly occured within a short period of time. As a bandleader therefore, Bunny Berigan got started rather quickly, and remarkably successfully.
The Berigan band that opened at the Madhattan Room of Hotel Pennsylvania on April 29, 1937 had been in existence for barely four months. In fact, the actual personnel of that band was almost totally different from the one Bunny oragnized in early 1937. The only holdovers were trombonist/vocalist Ford Leary, guitarist Tom Morganelli and bassist Arnold Fishkind. The reason for this turnover was that Bunny had been making personnel changes to strengthen his band. This process of musical chairs continued into late June or early July. After that, the Berigan band personnel remained intact, with one notable exception, into 1938. (1) (Above right: 28 year-old Bunny Berigan in a photo that was a part of a series of photos taken for promotional purposes in June of 1937.)
Through 1936 and into 1937, Bunny was a client of the powerful personal manager Arthur Michaud. Michaud was also Tommy Dorsey’s personal manager, and would later represent Gene Krupa and Jack Teagarden, among others. With Michaud’s guidance, Bunny had been a featured performer on the now legendary CBS network radio program The Saturday Night Swing Club, appearing weekly on that program from its inception in June of 1936 until February of 1937, when his duties as a full-time bandleader made it impossible for him to continue with SNSC. Michaud, initially with the assistance of the Rockwell-O’Keefe Booking Agency (later called General Artists/Amusement Corporation), had secured a place for the Berigan band on the Mutual Broadcasting System’s weekly radio program called Fun in Swingtime. Bunny’s association with that show lasted from mid-March to mid-October of 1937. It was a sponsored (by Admiracion Shampoo) high-level program that was aired nationwide on Sunday evenings, and would provide much exposure for Bunny and his band, and continue the process of building the Berigan name with fans of swing music across the country. It also provided a financial base that allowed him to build the band’s library of musical arrangements, and secure the services of musicians who shared his strong jazz orientation, while at the same time were able to perform written music with accuracy and verve.

Bunny Berigan in early 1937 with his management team. L-R: Arthur Michaud, BB, Tommy Dorsey and probably John Gluskin.(2)
Michaud, in conjunction with Rockwell-O’Keefe, had also been working to get Berigan a deal with a record company. But due to the politics of the record business then, they could not at first sign Bunny with the Victor label, the top record label of the 1930s, where both Benny Goodman and Tommy Dorsey had been recording successfully. (Placing Bunny with Victor been the goal of everyone involved with the Berigan band’s management from the beginning.) Finally, after complicated backstage maneuvering over a period of weeks in late February and early March 1937, Berigan ended up with a one-year Victor recording contract, which was signed in mid-March.
An agreement was also reached for the Berigan band to follow Benny Goodman’s band into the Madhattan Room of Hotel Pennsylvania in New York City at the end of April, with frequent sustaining (non-sponsored) CBS radio broadcasts. Those would also boost the Berigan name and music. Lastly, Bunny would be represented by Music Corporation of America (MCA), the largest and most powerful band booking agency in the nation. Thus, the business side of the Berigan band had reached maturity before its musical side. Bunny and his band found themselves in a place in the world of swing in a matter of weeks that for most bands that achieved succes would take months, indeed sometimes years, to reach.
Although Bunny was ecstatic about having and leading his own band, he was greatly concerned that the band he presented to the public be as good as possible. But he knew that no matter how good the individual musicians in his band might be, it simply required time for them to coalesce as a performing unit so that they would sound and feel good as a band.

The Berigan band in the rehearsal space in the offices of Music Corporation of America in Manhattan in early 1938. Discernable faces include, front L-R: Georgie Auld, Joe Dixon, Mike Doty; middle: Irving Goodman, Al George, Tom Morganelli; back: Dave Tough. Berigan is in the middle facing the band. To his right is Arthur Michaud. Bunny appears to be talking with Mike Doty.
Contrary to popular mythology, Bunny Berigan was very serious about bandleading. He had a musical vision which was to build a band that would to the degree possible, reflect his own fiery musical persona, yet at the same time be a first-rate dance band. The dance band part was essential for any big band during the swing era, because dancers were the largest consumers of the music of all big bands then. So throughout the spring of 1937 and into the summer, he painstakingly improved the personnel of his band, chair by chair. He also rehearsed his band often and rigorously, but not so rigorously that he beat the life out of the music. His objective was to get the band to play together relexedly, yet at the same time, to swing. That is exactly what we hear in the recordings of “Swanee River” that are presented with this post.
The performances of the Berigan band on the recordings and airchecks made in the spring of 1937 reveal a solid and enthusiastic band that was in the process of finding its musical identity. The arrangements, though quite good and varied, had no discernible style, and that was precisely what Bunny wanted. The band’s style was provided in large measure by his expressive trumpet, as both leader of the brass and as a soloist. The ensemble passages in some early Berigan band recordings are a bit rough at times, but at other times are thrillingly together and swinging.
The soloists other than Bunny, though clearly in control of their instruments, had a long way to go to reflect their charismatic leader’s jazz sensibilities. But then, Bunny was unique as a trumpeter. His playing at this time is quintessential. In these performances we hear the same inspired jazz soloist whose indelible stamp had been applied to the countless recordings he made in the early and mid-1930s. The features of his trumpet style included, in addition to great technique and passion, glissandi, slurs, scoops, rips, doits, half-valve effects, lip vibrato, growls and rasps. He also used a wide variety of muting devices, some conventional like straight and cup mutes, some unconventional, like a felt beret and a kazoo. Also on display are his lovely warm open trumpet sound in all registers, his acute sense of musical form and drama, and above all, his irresistible, joyous swing.
The story – part two – Berigan at Victor.
The commercial recording Bunny Berigan made of “Swanee River” took place on May 13, 1937 at Bunny’s second recording session for Victor Records. At that time, the Berigan band was in its second month of a residency at Hotel Pennsylvania that would eventually be extended into early July. (April 29 to July 6 or 7.) They were also in their second month as the featured band on the Mutual network show Fun in Swingtome. Their first Fun in Swingtime show aired on April 18, and they series would continue into October. So the Berigan band was very busy doing high-level work in and around the New York City area all through the spring of 1937.
Both the April 1 and May 13 Victor recording sessions were produced by Leonard Joy. Joy was respected by most of the musicians whose recordings he supervised at Victor. He was a polished, pipe-smoking Ivy Leaguer who dressed beautifully, and behaved like a diplomat (and a psychologist) in the recording studio. His job was to get the bands that made records for Victor to record mostly average (at best) pop tunes to satisfy his superiors and the music publishers, while at the same time, to cheerlead (or psyche-out) the musicians in the studio so that they would summon the enthusiasm required to inject some life into these performances. He was remarkably successful at doing these things. (Above left: Leonard Joy talks with Bunny Berigan in Victor’s 24th Street recording studio in Manhattan.)
Based on his interactions with Bunny Berigan in the recording studio, Joy developed high regard for Bunny as a bandleader and as a trumpet soloist. He found that Berigan was a relaxed leader who managed to get very good performances from his musicians by leading them with passion, enthusiasm, serious musicianship, and humor.
Although Bunny’s reputation as an exciting trumpet soloist had preceded him, Joy also found that he was not one to rest on his laurels. In the studio, Bunny usually dug deeper than most soloists to make his playing special. In many instances, Bunny’s playing was the only thing of distinction on many of the drearly pop tunes he was required to record for Victor. This can certainly be said for the first eight recordings Berigan made for Victor in the spring of 1937.
It is my informed speculation that Bunny asked Joy if he could step outside of the Victor Records paradigm after he had made those eight recordings, and record something that he thought would appeal to the people who were starting to buy his Victor records. Joy likely told him that if he successfully waxed the four pop tunes Victor had assigned him on the May 13 recording date, then he could record the “special” chart he had been working on with arranger Larry Clinton (3) on “Swanee River.” (Above right: another photo of Berigan that was a part of a series of photos taken for promotional purposes in June of 1937.)
The music:
Bunny Berigan was not known as an arranger. However, he was a bandleader who had very definite ideas about how he wanted the music his bands played to sound. He rarely altered what any of his arrangers wrote because he often told them before they wrote anything what he wanted. Usually he communicated to them rather clearly what he wanted to hear. Of course, Bunny’s trumpet playing was always at the center of the arrangements he commissioned. What often happened however is that after he and his musicians had played a new arrangement for a while, subtle, evolutionary changes began to occur. Bunny liked that and his sidemen liked that because it kept the music fresh. Audiences however did not like it when the Berigan band played music they were familiar with from recordings in a different manner than what was on the records. This was especially true for recordings that were hits with audiences. The most well-known example of this is Bunny’s theme song, “I Can’t Get Started with You.” Audiences expected to hear Bunny play that exactly as he recorded it at least once on each gig. Other examples are: “Trees,” “Night Song” and “Caravan.”
What is unusual about the arrangement Bunny commissioned from Larry Clinton on “Swanee River” is that despite his instructions to Clinton beforehand, after Larry delivered the arrangement, and the Berigan band began to rehearse it and play it on gigs, Bunny found it necessary to make some revisions. Those changes, whatever they might have been, were substantial enough to justify Bunny putting his name on the Victor record as co-arranger with Larry Clinton.
The Victor recording performance of “Swanee River” is a fairly straightforward showcase for Berigan’s straight-muted trumpet. After a bright four-bar introduction played by the ensemble, Bunny steps forward with sixteen swinging bars wherein he paraphrases the main melody. Then he improvises for another sixteen bars. The band perks up for a joyful rendering of the secondary melody, then Bunny returns to play a bit more jazz to end the first half of the recording.
The second half showcases Bunny’s protoge’ and pet, tenor saxophonist Georgie Auld, who would celebrate his eighteenth!! birthday six days after this recording was made. Young Mr. Auld, along with a number of other musicians, had been involved in the personnel changes in the new Berigan band that took place through the first months of 1937. Pianist Les Burness was a member of the very first band Bunny had in early 1937. But he left because Bunny wanted Joe Lippman to be both his band’s pianist and chief arranger. Prior to joining Berigan, Burness had been playing a gig in Greenwich Village with Georgie Auld. When an opening for a tenor player in Bunny’s band occurred, Burness recommended Auld. Bunny went to hear Auld, liked what he heard, and hired him.(4)
Auld was an exuberant person who had great command of his instrument, read music fluently, and wanted to play solos at every opportunity. This all pleased Bunny Berigan, because he needed others in his band to take some of the solo load off of him.(5) Auld had his own sound and ideas about jazz from the beginning of his association with Berigan, and Bunny never told him what to play of how to play. As we can hear from his solos on this recording and the one below, Georgie turned in quite creditable improvisations, including a deft interpolation of a snippet of George Gershwin’s “Oh, Lady Be Good” on the live recording. Behind him the band churns and drummer George Wettling adds cymbal crashes strategically.
The final sequence has the band swinging nicely before Bunny returns to add a bit more spicy jazz. The brassy tracts just before Bunny’s last solo and after it were certainly written by Larry Clinton.
This is a very good recording. Steve Lipkins, who leads the brass in fine fashion throughout, made a few insightful comments about this band and their leader: “…it was mainly a group of young kids bursting with talent and enthusiasm. …Bunny’s instincts were so good that he wound up with a good band.”(5) (Above left: the rhythm section of Bunny Berigan’s band photographed on the roof of Hotel Pennsylvania in June of 1937. L-R: Tom Morganelli, Arnold Fishkind, George Wettling and Joe Lippman.)
A bit more story – Berigan and Victor through the end of 1937:

Berigan’s recording of “Swanee River” became his first hit on the Victor label, and it opened the door a crack for Mr. B. to advocate with Victor’s producers to allow him to record other arrangements that presented his trumpeting and the Berigan band in a good light. Leonard Joy supervised Bunny’s next Victor recording session on June 18, and then the one after that on June 25. At the June 25 session, Bunny was permitted to record two of his special arrangements, “Frankie and Johnny,” and “Mahogany Hall Stomp.” The latter recording was Bunny’s paean to his idol, Louis Armstrong. “Frankie and Johnny” became his second hit for Victor. Then, it appears that Eli Oberstein was assigned to produce Berigan’s recordings on the Victor label. This did not negatively affect the quality of recordings Bunny made for Victor, at least not at first. Berigan essentials “I Can’t Get Started” and “The Prisoner’s Song” were recorded at his August 7, 1937 recording session, then “Caravan” and ” A Study in Brown” were recorded on August 18. After that, there was a definite fall-off of recordings of special arrangements by the Berigan band until December 23. At that recording session, Bunny and the Berigan band were riding high after their very successful first tour of ballrooms and theaters. They were permitted to record five instrumentals, all of which show off Bunny’s trumpet playing and the band very well. Bunny’s relationship with Victor through 1938, regrettably, would not be as positive as it had been through 1937.
***************
“Swanee River”
Composed by Stephen Foster; arranged by Larry Clinton and Bunny Berigan.
Recorded by Bunny Berigan and His Orchestra in performance on the NBC Magic Key of RCA radio show on June 13, 1937 in New York.
Bunny Berigan, trumpet, directing: Steve Lipkins and Irving Goodman trumpets; Thomas Ball “Sonny” Lee, first trombone, and Morey Samel, trombone; Sid Perlmutter, first alto saxophone; Joe Dixon, alto saxophone; Georgie Auld and Clyde Rounds, tenor saxophones; Joe Lippman, piano; Tommy Morganelli, guitar; Arnold Fishkind, bass; George Wettling, drums.
As a special treat, here is another recording of “Swanee River” made one month after the Victor recording. As one would expect, there are differences in this performance in Bunny’s solos and in those of Georgie Auld. In addition to the spirited performance given by the Berigan band, the fidelity of this recording is outstanding.
The recordings presented with this post were digitally remastered by Mike Zirpolo.
Notes and links:
(1) The one personnel change Bunny made at the end of 1937 was to fire drummer George Wettling. The reasons for this seemed to be that Wettling was drinking too much, and that was affecting his performance negatively. Also, Wettling developed a personality conflict with pianist/arranger Joe Lippman, which culminated with a fistfight in which Lippman was injured. Lippman was the chief arranger for Bunny’s band, and a good one. He remained with the band for some time after the departure of Wettling.
(2) John Gluskin was described by several of the musicians in the early Berigan band as “a money man,” someone who invested in promising new bands, usually with loans to cover shortfalls in the band’s weekly expenses. Gluskin had in 1935 and 1936 invested in Tommy Dorsey’s new band.
(3) Larry Clinton was an arranger who sometimes played trumpet, trombone and clarinet. He began his big-time musical career as an arranger for the very popular Casa Loma band in 1935. In the spring of 1936, Clinton began working for Jimmy Dorsey, whose band was then being featured on the NBC Kraft Music Hall radio show with Bing Crosby. That show was then emanating from the NBC studios in Los Angeles, and Clinton went there to work with Dorsey. He returned to New York to again work for the Casa Loma band at the end of 1936. He continued working with Casa Loma through much of 1937, though not on an exclusive basis. (His original novelty tune/arrangement “The Dipsy Doodle” was recorded by Tommy Dorsey on October 14, 1937, and became a hit.) In mid-October 1937, Clinton began making recordings for RCA-Bluebird as the leader of an ad hoc studio band. Those recordings sold well, and soon Clinton was the leader of a full-time, touring swing band.
(4) The details of Bunny Berigan hiring Georgie Auld come from the White Materials, February 19, 1937. Auld likely joined the Berigan band around March 1, 1937.
(5) It must be mentioned that the burden Berigan took on by playing the solos in his band (a major challenge the way he did it), as well as playing at least 50% of the first trumpet parts, placed a huge physical strain on him. In order to allow him some time for rest, he needed other soloists in his band. The soloists who eventually did this were: Georgie Auld on tenor saxophone; Joe Dixon on clarinet and alto saxophone; and Sonny Lee on trombone. A bit later, Joe Bushkin came into the Berigan band and was often given solos on piano.
(5) White Materials, February 19, 1937.
Here are some links to other early performances by Bunny Berigan and his band:
And the most famous of all Berigan recordings: https://swingandbeyond.com/2016/10/05/i-cant-get-started-1937-bunny-berigan/
For much more information about all things Berigan, check out this link: https://bunnyberiganmrtrumpet.com/
Be the first to comment